After finding a set of animal cookie cutters at the thrift store, I decided to make some faux animal crackers. Read on to see how:
**********
Disclosure - This post may contain affiliate links. If a purchase is made through an affiliate link then (at no additional cost to you) I will receive a commission. You can read more about affiliate links here
**********
Here is the Wilton set that I found for $1.99.
Using Crayola Model Magic and some Apple Barrel acrylic paint in Classic Caramel, I mixed in the paint until I had a nice beigy color.
(This post will show you step-by-step the mixing process)
Once I had the color that I liked, I rolled the Model Magic out on some waxed paper and stuck in my cutters. Rather than pull the 'crackers' right out and spoil the shapes, I popped the Model Magic filled cutters into the freezer. After freezing the shapes came right out of the cutters without trouble.
I let the shapes thaw, then fully dry before moving on to decorating.
Starting with puffy paint, I outlined the shapes then added more paint to fill them in with 'icing'.
While the paint was still wet I then added in the tiny foam beads to look like sprinkles, and let everything dry.
Aren't they cute?! I put them in a jar with a few other faux cookie treats and stashed them in my faux cookie cabinet. You can see more about that cabinet here.
And that's how I made my Model Magic animal crackers.
**********
Interested in more fake bake crafts?
I've gathered all of my tutorials and collections into this resource page.
**********
I hope you enjoyed this how to post, thanks for stopping by!
-Jennifer
© Studio 27 by Jennifer Adams 2025
**********
This post was added to the following link parties:
Do you like the convenience of crafting or organizing with instantly available digital downloads?
Check out this week's features from my Etsy shop:
**********
Are you thinking of starting a blog or a seasoned author who wants to get organized? This 115 page printable bundle is for you! I created these pages for my own use and found them so helpful I thought I should make them available for other bloggers as well. Click the link below the image to read the full item description.



















These turned out so cute, Jennifer! What a fun idea and such a great thrift store find with those cookie cutters.
ReplyDeleteYou are so good at making these fake bakes. 🙂
Thank you, I have a lot of fun with it!
DeleteAlways inspirational and so creative, Jennifer! Loved these as a snack when I was a kid! I tink I will have to try them again soon!
ReplyDeleteDon't forget to join us over at the Creatively Crafty Linky Party every Wednesday through Sunday
https://creativelybeth.com/creative-crafts-linky-party-2/
Pinned!
Creatively, Beth
I'll be there!
Delete